Bay Street Players is a live event venue in Eustis, FL. There are 33 upcoming events listed here right now, including A Midsummer Night's Dream, Carrie - The Musical, Peter and The Starcatcher and Avenue Q. The next one is Carrie - The Musical on Friday, October 30, 2026 at 7:30 PM.
Pick an event to open the seating map for that date. Section layouts can change with the stage setup, so check the map for the specific event before you choose seats.
Upcoming events at Bay Street Players
- Oct30Tickets
- Oct31Tickets
- Nov1Tickets
- Nov5Tickets
- Nov6Tickets
- Nov7Tickets
- Nov8Tickets
- Nov13Tickets
- Nov14Tickets
- Nov15Tickets
- Jan15Tickets
- Jan16Tickets
- Jan17Tickets
- Jan21Tickets
- Jan22Tickets
- Jan23Tickets
- Jan24Tickets
- Jan29Tickets
- Jan30Tickets
- Jan31Tickets
- Apr2Tickets
- Apr3Tickets
- Apr4Tickets
- Apr8Tickets
- Apr9Tickets
- Apr10Tickets
- Apr11Tickets
- Apr16Tickets
- Apr17Tickets
- Apr18Tickets
- Jun4Tickets
- Jun5Tickets
- Jun6Tickets
Who is playing Bay Street Players
- A Midsummer Night's Dream · 10 dates
- Carrie - The Musical · 10 dates
- Peter and The Starcatcher · 10 dates
- Avenue Q · 3 dates